The Puritans’ journey to the New World was driven by their belief that they were on a divine mission to establish a “city upon a hill”—a model Christian society to serve as an example to the world. Their “errand in the wilderness,” a term used to describe their migration to America, was both a physical and spiritual journey. Three influential Puritan figures—Reverend John Cotton, Governor John Winthrop, and Mary Rowlandson—each offered unique perspectives on this mission. Their views highlight the challenges, purpose, and hardships of the Puritan experience in the wilderness.
John Cotton’s View of the Puritan Errand
Reverend John Cotton, a prominent Puritan minister, focused on the spiritual and moral aspect of the Puritans’ journey. In his writings and sermons, Cotton argued that the Puritans were called to establish a pure, godly community in the New World.
For Cotton, the wilderness was not just a physical space to be conquered, but a place for spiritual purification—a testing ground for God’s people. The errand was not simply about building a society but about maintaining a covenant with God. This covenant required the Puritans to honor God’s laws and establish a holy community.
Cotton’s views reflect the Puritan belief that the wilderness provided an opportunity for both spiritual growth and purification. The errand was an important mission to live according to God’s will and to create a community that embodied these values.
John Winthrop and the Vision of a “City upon a Hill”
Governor John Winthrop, one of the most prominent Puritan leaders in America, provided the most famous articulation of the Puritans’ errand. In his sermon A Model of Christian Charity (1630), Winthrop described their mission as the creation of a “city upon a hill.” This meant they were to build a model Christian society that would serve as an example to the world.
Winthrop’s vision centered on the idea of communal responsibility. He believed the Puritans’ success or failure would directly impact Christianity’s reputation. His famous phrase, “we shall be as a city upon a hill,” captures the Puritans’ desire to demonstrate to the world that living according to God’s will was key to a prosperous society.
For Winthrop, the wilderness was not an obstacle but a setting for a divine experiment in godliness. The errand was a collective effort to show that a righteous society could flourish when aligned with God’s laws.
Mary Rowlandson and the Puritan Struggle in the Wilderness
Mary Rowlandson’s perspective on the Puritan errand is unique because it is deeply personal. In her narrative, The Sovereignty and Goodness of God (1682), Rowlandson recounts her capture by Native Americans during King Philip’s War in 1676. Through her captivity, she explores the spiritual nature of her suffering and survival.
Unlike Cotton and Winthrop, Rowlandson’s view of the wilderness is less idealistic. For her, it was a place of intense struggle and hardship, where she faced both physical danger and a sense of spiritual silence from God. Yet, through this suffering, Rowlandson came to understand God’s sovereignty and providence.
Rowlandson’s narrative suggests that the Puritans’ errand was not merely about creating a successful society, but about enduring trials and remaining faithful to God’s plan, even in times of adversity. The wilderness, for Rowlandson, was a place where God’s purposes were being fulfilled, even when His presence seemed hidden.
Conclusion
John Cotton, John Winthrop, and Mary Rowlandson each offered distinct perspectives on the Puritans’ errand in the wilderness. Cotton emphasized the spiritual mission to maintain faith and purity, Winthrop envisioned a model Christian society to set an example for the world, and Rowlandson’s personal narrative illustrated the role of suffering and God’s sovereignty in fulfilling the Puritan mission.
Together, these views offer a rich understanding of the Puritans’ journey in the New World. They faced both physical challenges and spiritual tests, but through these struggles, they believed they were fulfilling a divine mission that would serve as a beacon of Christian faith for generations to come.